Libya Crisis Map Deployment Report

We have just completed the after action review of the SBTF deployment of the Libya Crisis Map. You can view the report as a Google Doc here. Please feel free to add comments and questions as this is an open and editable document. The entire point of this report is to catalyze conversation and learning. This is a live document and should by no means be considered the final report. Our space is defined by change and continuous learning, so the best we can do is share our own analysis in the form of an open and editable Google Doc and invite the community to “finish” the report with their comments. To be sure, the real work happens in the comments, discussions and actions that ensue.

This after action review is primarily based on the feedback from SBTF volunteers and official responders (see in particular the extensive feedback already posted as comments). The report helps to improve SBTF internal protocols including those on liaising with a variety of partners. Furthermore, this report contributes directly to the on-going development of a working interface between humanitarian organizations and V&TCs. Obviously, the SBTF model is not the only possible model and it focuses specifically on live mapping.

The UN OCHA team has also prepared a lessons learned document summarizing important lessons from Libya (and Japan) crisis map deployments. This report was based on a full day meeting in New York that took place on June 15,. The meeting was organized by OCHA and included a number of partners from the Volunteer and Technical Community (V&TC) including the SBTF. This OCHA report, available here, provides important findings and recommendations that complement those of this SBTF review.

There is a wide range of opinions on the usefulness of the Libya Crisis Map. During the June 15 meeting in New York, OCHA staff who were most directly engaged in the initiative reaffirmed the value of the live map. They also recognized the need to provide more timely feedback on how these maps are used in future deployments. Others at the UN who were less directly involved in the project have argued that the “use case” for live maps has yet to be demonstrated. Some have highlighted that the speed and willingness of volunteers to collect and organize information as requested by OCHA (in particular for the 3Ws) was a great support at the start of the crisis before regular information management protocols within OCHA were activated.

OCHA’s own Brendan McDonald—the head of the Information Services Section who activated the SBTF for Libya—had this to say in a formal thank you note sent to all volunteers:

In an August interview with, Brendan added the following:

“If you go back a couple of years, all of this information probably would have been available, but it would have been seen as noise coming at you in multiple formats”, he says. “Libya Crisis Map has done an extraordinary job to aggregate all of this information.”

Whatever other views are out there, we hope this review will encourage constructive discussion on the future of partnerships between VTCs and traditional responders. This is why we very much welcome your views on this report, either as comments to this blog post or as comments directly on the Google Doc.

The review was prepared by the SBTF team and therefore should not be considered as an independent or exhaustive evaluation. The report was also written on a purely voluntary basis and thus was not funded in any way.

The SBTF would not exist without the dedicated and talented volunteers who have joined the team. Sincere thanks go to all SBTF volunteers who contributed to the Libya Crisis Map project. We would also like to thank Crisis Commons, the Humanitarian OpenStreetMap Team, Humanity Road, NetHope, the UN OCHA teams in Colombia and Geneva, and UN Global Pulse for their support. Finally, we should note that this project would never have taken off had OCHA not taken the bold decision to engage the SBTF in the first place.


This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

12 Trackbacks

  1. By Civil-Military Digest - September | Asia Pacific Civil-Military Centre of Excellence on September 22 at 4:17 am

    [...] Libya Crisis Map Deployment Report, [...]

  2. By The Standby Volunteer Task Force: One Year On | iRevolution on September 25 at 5:57 pm

    [...] were it not for them, the Libya Crisis Map that we launched for UN OCHA would have looked like this (as would all the other [...]

  3. By Answer to Matthew Levinger and TechChange | Diary of a Crisis Mapper on October 28 at 4:35 pm

    [...] Levinger? By providing FREE training material and information, by sharing lessons learned (like the Libya and Colombia report) , by engaging people in discussion about this and offering them free support [...]

  4. By SBTF Recognized in Online Volunteer Award! on December 9 at 1:24 pm

    [...] is available online here, which includes this video describing the SBTF’s work on the Libya Crisis Map. Sincere thanks to Andrej Verity for his comments in the video [...]

  5. By Data Protection Standards 2.0 on February 14 at 12:44 pm

    [...] particular has developed in the last year several documents in order to manage those issue: in the Libya deployment the verification protocols designed by the SBTF were accepted and revised by UNOCHA before being [...]

  6. By Mobile Technologies, Crisis Mapping & Disaster Response: My Talk at #WMC12 | iRevolution on February 27 at 6:45 am

    [...] for disaster response because they can provide real-time situational awareness, like this official UN Crisis Map of Libya. Because the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UN OCHA) did not have [...]

  7. By Crisis Mapping Syria: Automated Data Mining and Crowdsourced Human Intelligence | iRevolution on March 25 at 4:51 pm

    [...] that the International Criminal Court (ICC) and Amnesty International (AI) closely followed the Libya Crisis Map last [...]

  8. By Crisis Mapping Syria: Automated Data Mining and Crowdsourced Human Intelligence - The Ushahidi Blog on March 27 at 11:13 pm

    [...] that the International Criminal Court (ICC) and Amnesty International (AI) closely followed the Libya Crisis Map last [...]

  9. By Crowdsourcing Humanitarian Convoys in Libya | iRevolution on April 6 at 7:19 am

    [...] taking place at exactly the same time in support of the UN’s humanitarian relief operations: Libya Crisis Map. Much of the content added to the map was sourced from social media. Could the #LibyaConvoy project [...]

  10. By Does the Humanitarian Industry Have a Future in The Digital Age? | iRevolution on April 9 at 11:18 am

    [...] since Haiti to provide the “surge capacity” requested by the latter; this includes UN OCHA in Libya and Colombia, UNHCR in Somalia and WHO in Libya, to name a few. In fact, these groups even have [...]

  11. By PeopleBrowsr: Next-Generation Social Media Analysis for Humanitarian Response? | iRevolution on July 11 at 9:43 am

    [...] of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) activated the Standby Volunteer Task Force (SBTF) to crisis map Libya last year, for example, SBTF volunteers manually monitored hundreds of Twitter handles, news sites for [...]

  12. By E-diplomacy and Beyond | Le blog de la revue Politique Etrangère on July 31 at 8:01 am

    [...] media. Although it was generally hailed as having great potential to contribute to operations, in a deployment report, the crowd-sourced Libya Crisis Map project is the perfect example of how administrative lag [...]